Reader Reviews

 
image TURNING TOWARDS HOME
BY JAYNE BENTLEY, 1979
CATEGORY ROMANCE
MACFADDEN ROMANCE #224
Currently out of print

Reviewed by: Danyelle Warden
Reviewed by: Naomi Sinor
Reviewed by: Carole Coonrod
Reviewed by: Rebecca Becnel

As a long-time reader of JAK, being able to read TURNING TOWARDS HOME was a real treat. (Thanks Carole. I really appreciate you lending me the book!) Knowing that TTH was a very early novel, my initial expectations were somewhat low - I expected to see JAK style & themes, but perhaps less well developed characters or less fluid plot devices employed. I was pleasantly surprised to find TTH not only stands out as a mile-marker within an incredible writing career as an early sale, but the book reaches out & grabs the reader from page one. Amanda Chase is a heroine with an independent streak a mile wide with more courage than sense sometimes, and Rafe MacIntyre simply makes the reader drool. What more could one ask for?

This book is typical of MacFadden Romances & quite similar to Silhouette Romance or Harlequin Presents - not much sex, plenty of character development, some angst thrown in for flavor, & a "career woman" plot. Nevertheless, JAK is able to breathe life into a novel that could, in lesser talent's hands, be predictable & flat. TTH is nothing, if not a fun read!

There are several issues within TTH that would be considered dated & trite in the romance industry today, but readers must consider the 1979 publication date & realize that without long term commitment to romance, we would still be reading the Bronte sisters! Rafe is an alpha hero that could be upheld as their role model. Amanda battles the stifling restrictions of society's expectations of a career woman. Rafe manipulates Amanda in a manner that would be unheard of in the 1990s. All of these factors could detract from TTH, if not for the trademark JAK style & wit that move the plot along nicely.

Amanda's growth as a woman is a tribute to today's heroine as well as her role in 1979. Rafe's single-minded pursuit of Amanda makes readers long to find a mate with as much strength & focus. The couple's success in making their relationship work after a rocky start lends credence to "happily ever after." Thanks, Jayne, for another fine read.

Danyelle Warden


Amanda is a career woman who see's herself totally devoted to her job, to being independent and having her personal freedom. She's wary of the demands of the typical marriage and is very wary about having children. She knows children would limit the freedom she doesn't want to surrender...

Rafe is a man who knows what he wants. Amanda!

Amanda Chase is attending a convention related to her work. She has a duel purpose in attending the convention, in that she was to rendezvous with her co-worker Kirk Sheldon, whom she thought to surprise by getting to the convention a day early. Unfortunately (or fortunately)she interrupts the man she thought she would marry while he was occupied with a blond....hmm...enter our cowboy to the rescue, Senior Rafael Diego Esqueda MacIntyre, 50% Spanish, 50% Scottish and 100% MAN.

Amanda asks Rafe to dance with her to keep her away from Kirk, whom she has avoided like the Black Plague. Our cowboy is happy to be used...but for a price. He pretends to be the man who can be Amanda's partner and in a whirlwind week of romance and slight of hand, he gets his prize...marriage.

Our cowboy doesn't take NO for an answer and flat out lies in order to get our heroine into his clutches and onto his Arizona ranch to mother his two orphaned nieces.

He's lied about having kids or family, he lied about giving up his ranch to stay with Amanda in San Diego where her job is at, and he got rid of Amanda's job behind her back. If that's not enough, Amanda doesn't like horses and Rafe's ranch is an Arabian Horse Farm! Poor Amanda...impetuous Amanda...she's thinking her luck with men has gone from bad to worse...who can a girl trust?...

This story is fraught with tensions and conflicts. Rafe is convinced Amanda loves him and goes about convincing her in a heavy-handed, possessive and determined way. Amanda only knows the city life and is not happy about horses, a ready made family and no job. The tensions in the book are centered on the very important issues that woman today have to face everyday: how to balance or even if you can balance a life that includes raising children and a career outside of the home. Amanda is well aware that in most marriages, it's the woman who has to compromise and she has to decide whether or not the life Rafe is offering is what she wants (something totally new and outside her experience) or if she should go back to what she knows (her life in San Diego). Rafe doesn't care what she decides...she's his wife and that's that!

I enjoyed the book very much. It was a glimpse into how later JAK's feminine characters evolved to handle the same issues that Amanda faces. I was very happy to see a strong, spirited woman facing the business world and men as an equal and on her own terms. This doesn't seem to be typical of romances of this time (late 70's). The overriding theme to this book is a concept that is dear to my heart...HONOR. Do you honor your word or do you just pay lip service? Can you trust in someone's word or are you unworthy? These are questions that everyone faces in different aspects of their life. Overall I give this book 4.5 stars out of 5.

Naomi Sinor


Turning Towards Home is one of Jayne Ann Krentz's earlier novels, written under the pen name of Jayne Bentley. In style and character perspective, to me it was reminiscent of the approach she took in A Passionate Business which she wrote under her Stephanie James pen name. As she did in that book, in TTH, the hero and heroine did not actually have sex until the final pages of the book. Also similar in both books, the sexual tension was such throughout the book that it worked out fine to save the admittedly less-graphic-than-her-normal sex scene until the end.

Her heroine, Amanda Chase, is a city girl, holding down a job in San Diego. She is in Tucson at a convention when she meets the hero, Rafe MacIntyre, a cowboy. At first glance, though, it's clear he's not just any old cowboy but a man to be reckoned with.

Amanda starts the conference out by coming early and finding the man she planned to marry in bed with another woman. Amanda is a woman with high expectations and this man's lack of honor is unacceptable to her. In order to avoid having to talk with her former boyfriend, Amanda singles Rafe out in the crowd in the lounge and asks him to dance. Little does she know what she's getting into! Rafe has already marked her as his.

Determined to make her his and not frighten her with his domineering ways, Rafe spends the week of the convention letting Amanda see his more pliable side (such as it is), but when the end of the week comes, he puts his plan in gear. At its successful conclusion, she finds herself married!

Here is where Rafe's deception becomes even more obvious. On their wedding night, while Rafe is in the shower, a call comes in. On the other end of the line is Rafe's family - his two aunts and his two children. Amanda is stunned. Not only has she made it clear that she's a city girl, but also that children were not on her agenda. With this news, it's clear that Rafe had no plans to follow her to her home and life as she thought.

Read this story to find out how Rafe manages to redeem his honor in Amanda's eyes and how the two of them find that they are each other's future. I recommend this book.

Carole Coonrod


Amanda, the heroine of Turning Towards Home, is a strong willed, independent person who knows what she wants. She has her future all figured out. Enter Rafe MacIntyre, equally strong willed, determined to change her mind. The story opens with Amanda attempting to use the hero as a buffer for her soon to be ex-boyfriend. She finds herself falling in love with a man who seems willing to chuck everything to be with her. Set in the late '70s, it's not long before the two are wed. During that time period, it used to be important to make sure vows were exchanged before all hell broke loose. And it certainly does break loose. Life with Rafe confronts Amanda with everything she hoped to escape - motherhood, family ties, life on a horse ranch. She attempts to come to turns with all this, deal with her sexy, but altogether arrogant husband, and fend off another woman.

One of the best scene involve a battle of words and views between Amanda and Rafe in front of family and friends. At one point the heroine hauls off and hits the hero. Now we all know Jayne's hero can't let such an insult go without retaliation. But what will he do and how will the heroine respond? I can tell you the anticipation thrilled me. Another awesome part of the book involves a meeting between Amanda and her former boyfriend. Jayne finds a unique and unexpected way for the heroine to handle the situation. It shows how JAK puts her characters through the trite old scene only to complete debunk the same old results. It's definitely an early sign of the wit and drama expected from a JAK story. I highly recommend this story. You'll love it especially if you read romances back during the time this one came out. If you did, you'll fully appreciate it's originality. If you can get your hands on this book, grab it. The picture of the hero on the cover is horrible. Amanda's portrait isn't that flatter either. But the picture Jayne paints inside is enough to make this a wonderful story.

Rebecca Becnel


back to reviews

Return to the JAK Page